DARK WEB: STEVEN HICKEY’S ESSENTIAL GUIDE TO CREEPYPASTA – PART 39: SALLY (PLAY WITH ME)
As I’ve written here before in my coverage of 1999 and Where Bad Kids Go, there are few evils in the world as monstrous as those sick individuals who prey on children. It is the acts of the likes of the Moors Murderers, Fred and Rose West, and Ian Huntley that are the real world’s most disturbing horror stories. This week’s Dark Web feature is about a Pasta that combines elements of these true-life horrors with a traditional vengeful ghost story to chilling effect. This is the story of Sally, Play With Me.
The story of Sally first appeared online at author and DeviantArtist, La-Mishi-Mish’s (formerly Kiki-Hyuga) page on 29 February 2012. You can read it at: http://la-mishi-mish.deviantart.com/art/CreepyPasta-Play-with-me-287823665
It recounts the story of young Sally, a sweet eight-year-old girl who is full of the innocence of youth. However, she finds herself plunged into a nightmare when her abusive and manipulative uncle Johnny comes to visit. After a horrifying ordeal (which, thankfully, is implied rather than graphically described), she looks to tell her parents about what she went through. Unable to process what they’re being told, the girl’s mother and father enter a state of denial. Later, Johnny overhears the two discussing their concerns – and decides to punish the girl for breaking her silence. However, Sally’s story does not end there…
The writing gets a tiny bit rough at times – which is only to be expected when you take the author’s relative inexperience into account – however, the story is strong and shocking, and (like some of the very finest horror stories) there is a real sense of pathos to Play With Me. Even as she becomes something terrifying, one can never forget that Sally is a victim herself. In her own story, Sally is far from the worst monster.
In a lot of ways she is reminiscent of Ring’s Sadako (or Samara for those only familiar with the remake), a sympathetic innocent who becomes corrupted by the horrors inflicted upon her. However, lets us not forget that here in the West, children are regularly used to invoke fear. We have an ageing population, one that has every reason to fear the next, younger generation. After all, ultimately, they are going to replace each of us.
What’s more, young children are far less rational or controlled than grown-ups. Their emotions are volatile, their brains just alien enough to make them unpredictable, and their different view of the world makes children pretty unfathomable to a large section of adult society. Of course, corruption of youth and innocence is a huge part of the Creepypasta movement – it’s the reason why there are hundreds and hundreds of ‘lost episode’ pastas relating to children’s programmes, such as Squidward’s Suicide or Suicide Mouse, and (as far as I’m aware) not a single one related to adult programming such as The Sopranos, 24 or Breaking Bad. There’s something inherently unsettling about taking childhood, the time in which you were meant to be most carefree, most safe, and reawakening those deep dark fears that came with the times.
The official term for a fear of children is paedophobia, and the reasons for which somebody might be afflicted with it are many, but it’s clearly common enough for Hollywood to have taken notice. Spooky kids are bread and butter in horror movies, and Sally definitely falls into the spooky category. She’s also a character that has seen a predominantly warm welcome from the Creepypasta community. There are plenty of pictures of the character on DeviantArt, plus an unofficial spin-off story, Will You Play With Me?, which was posted over at Creepypasta.com by user D.S. Ozolnieks (http://www.creepypasta.com/will-you-play-with-me/). Will You Play With Me? tells the story of an unfortunate individual who happens to cross paths with Sally.
There are also plenty of those ever-present readings online, including one by the heavyweight champion of the Creepypasta Reading scene, Mr Creepypasta, (which you can listen to here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKJb4hU-4qc) and the equally impressive Creeps McPasta here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r3K6X2yXL44.
This is a character who has touched, and terrified, thousands of people, and as such has taken on iconic status with some sections of the fandom.
I was lucky enough to speak with the character’s creator, La-Mishi-Mish, and she gave me some frank, brave answers to my questions, answers which some readers may find upsetting.
Our interview follows below.
UK HORROR SCENE: In your own words, tell us a little about Sally/Play With Me?
LA-MISHI-MISH: Play With Me is based on an eight year old girl named Sally. It takes place during a summer in the Sixties, and unfortunately, it will be her last summer to experience any true happiness or freedom as a child. I won’t go into full detail into the story for those who are possibly interested in reading it, but it let’s just say it does not have a happy ending. Sally, however, is your typical ‘good daughter’ who wants to make her parents happy and proud of her. And people like her never deserve what she does go through.
UKHS: What served as your inspiration for the character?
LMM: Sally is 100% based and inspired off of my mother. I, again, won’t go into too much detail of her past, but my mother is a survivor of incest and many, many other things. She honestly should not be here alive after what she has been through, but I’m supremely grateful that she is. I honestly don’t know what I would do if she wasn’t here today. But despite everything my mother has gone through, she still lives every day to the fullest no matter what may come crashing down on her, and I wanted to incorporate that into Sally’s character, before and after her events in the story.
UKHS: Which idea came to you first, the image or the story?
LMM: The image came first. It wouldn’t surprise me if no one believes what I’ll say next but, my family and I are, ‘different’. Different as in we are able to see or feel spirits or anything paranormal. When I was little, I had two ‘imaginary friends’. One named Sally, the other Sarah. Sally wore pink, Sarah wore purple. Sally was a brunette while Sarah was blonde. Of course when I told my mother this, she never wrote it off as them being ‘imaginary’, but simply accepted that I, like her, could see spirits/ghosts. I don’t see them as much now, but I like to think they’re still here watching over us. Anything I do happen to see is out of the corner of my eye, my mother and brother Logan however, can see them clearly, as if they are real people.
But after I came up with my initial idea of who my protagonist would look like in my story, it was then I decided to base one of the many things my mother had gone through herself as a child, as the story itself. Albeit a far ‘tamer’ version. But my mother always wanted to ‘be’ a cartoon character in some way, so I created Sally and Play With Me in her honor.
UKHS: Are you a fan of Creepypasta? If so, what is your favourite Creepypasta by a creator other than yourself?
LMM: I’m a fan of SOME Creepypasta, but not all. If I may be honest, I haven’t been up to date with any recently popular CP’s. But if I was to choose a handful of my personal it would be these: My very first Creepypasta story I ever read, was BEN: Haunted Majora’s Mask. It’s quite a read, but definitely worth every minute you spend on it. Creeped me out to no end. Then there’s the unforgettable Jeff the Killer, Mr. Widemouth, Clifton Bunny Man, Huntsville Camping Trip, The Thing That Stalks The Fields, Eyeless Jack, Smile.Dog, Squidward’s Suicide, Cupcakes, The Willow Men, Julia Legare, Tourist Trap, LSD: Dream Emulator, Bubby the Clown, Herobrine, Disneyland 1999, Lavender Town, Russian Sleep Experiment, just to name a few. They’re all great in my opinion.
UKHS: Why do you think Creepypastas in general, and especially Sally/Play With Me, have been so popular with the fans?
LMM: I think Creepypasta itself is online scary stories that can be shared and told countless of times. People love scary stories, no matter how scary or even silly it may be. Seeing how you can use the internet for almost anything, creating and sharing something like stories would be easy to do.
I’m not sure how my story got so popular, but in a way I’m kinda honored, if not flattered it did. I’m not too confident in my written work as I am in my drawings, but it gives me some feeling of accomplishment.
UKHS: Which writers, horror or otherwise, do you consider yourself a fan of?
LMM: I don’t read much literature (I’m more into manga), but from what I remember, one of my favorite authors was Laurie Faria Stolarz and her book series, Blue is for Nightmares. I unfortunately only got up to a certain point in the series because I couldn’t find the rest of the books, but from what I remember it’s a wonderful series. I highly recommend it to anyone who is into mystery novels.
UKHS: What work of your own are you most proud of?
LMM: That’s a tough question, I’m very hard on myself at times with my artwork, whether it be drawn or written. But right now I am pretty proud of my Play With Me story. I never expected a silly little story I made in honor of my mom would get popular in any form. Art wise? That’s a little tough because, there’s tons of pieces that I personally feel proud of, but too many to list on here.
UKHS: The fans are very passionate about the character. Are there any examples of fan art, such as images, films or readings, in particular that have impressed you?
LMM: Yes actually, I do have a few favourites that I’d be happy to show you.
UKHS: Your artwork is incredible. Where did you learn to create such evocative images? How do you get inspiration for the creative process?
LMM: Awah, thank you so much haha, I’m flattered to hear that. I first started drawing when I was five. I always loved watching my aunt Cheyenne draw little comics and characters, so when I turned eight I wanted her to teach me how to draw. She taught me the basics, but after that I’ve been self taught. I wish it was easier to ‘print’ out the images one can visualise in one’s head, but when my art does come close to it, it’s a great accomplishment. My inspiration almost always stems from my emotions to my music that I listen to. A simple song can easily spark up many upon many ideas for pictures.
UKHS: Will you ever return to the story of Sally in the future? And what else can your fans look forward to from you in the days ahead?
LMM: I’m actually in the process of giving my Play With Me story a sort of ‘reboot’. Not to replace the previous story, mind you, just to have a little fun to add more to it and see if the public will like it. I will admit that I could have done lots more to my story, but regardless of what anyone says about it, I am happy with how the story turned out. I don’t know if you’ve read my fan story Origin of Eyeless Jack (http://la-mishi-mish.deviantart.com/art/Origin-of-Eyeless-Jack-363990065), but I also plan on creating one for BEN: Haunted Majoras Mask. They have nothing to do with the original, of course, but they too are also for fun. And in the future, I just hope people enjoy what I continue to post up in my gallery, whether it be literature or artwork.
UKHS: And finally, are there any sites or projects that you’d like me to send my readers to for more of your work?
LMM: Well, there’s obviously my deviantART page: La-Mishi-Mish.deviantart.com, that’s where I post most if not all my work. Then there’s my artblog over on Tumblr, http://artofakiki.tumblr.com. And finally, if one is even interested, my YouTube channel. I have tons of old videos of my first years on YouTube itself, but now has small voice acting tidbits of the Five Nights at Freddy’s animatronics and other shenanigans. Just search up ‘La Mishi Mish’ and you should be able to find me with no problem (UKHS: the channel is here: https://www.youtube.com/user/HyuugaKiki100). With my current living conditions, I am unable to upload constant videos on my channel, but hopefully one day that will change.
UKHS: Thank you for speaking with me.
Sally is one of those Creepypasta characters who has become an integral part of the scene for several fans. Join me next time when I’ll be speaking with the creator of another iconic web-horror character…